overrated nfl players

[jimmytheg]

yeah i also cant agree with you here at all....in any way. If in qualifying who the best is, do you talk in terms of who means more to his team, or who puts up the best numbers? In either of those circumstances, Vick is nowhere near the top.

How can you say Vick is better than Moss, or Owens, or Manning, or Caulpepper. Nobody in the history of the league has thrown for 5 td's in 1 game, 3 times out of 5, like Caulpepper has this year.

Vick has fumbled more than any other Qb this year, and like a previous poster said is 23rd in QB rating. These are not the stats of the best player in football, hands down

[GeoffM]

By best player, I meant most talent. Numbers are not everything, they are affected by the team that is fielded around you.

Noone has more talent than this guy, in terms of all-around offensive talent. He has a cannon for an arm, runs like the wind (better than Randall ever did). His numbers aren't great, but you know what, at 5-2, he gets the job done. This team won 5 games all last year, and now he has started every game and they have 5 wins already, and you also have to understand that the Falcons don't want to see their star get burned out, or injured (again) by having him run whenever he wants. When he does run, though, it's as though his team is in the red zone.