NFL Rookie of the Year

[Reel Deal]

Who should it be?

[X-Longshot-X]

Vince Young, No doubt, No player has shown more leadership and dedication and impacted his team more this year than Vince.

[juiCe[3x]]

I would like to say AJ Hawk but it will be between Hester and Young. I would give it to Young but Hester might get.

[Zybomb]

There's no chance that will get it because

1) He's a wide receiver

2) He comes from Hofstra (a school little known unless your from NY)

But Marques Colston deserves some serious props.

Outside of that definately Vince Young. Leadership and completely turning the season around for the Titans, despite only average at best passing numbers

I'm sure you may have a compaign for Jones-Drew RD though, and I cant say it isnt warrented. A "backup" certaintly does not play like that and put up those numbers!

[Talking Poker]

Hester is awesome but won't get it.

Jones-Drew had a very good year, but he should be no more of a ROY candidate than Reggie Bush was, IMO.

Colston deserves it more than anyone, IMO, but they'll give it to Young.

[Defendant]

Uh...

Joseph Addai?

[Reel Deal]

Why? His numbers are way ahead of Bush.

[GeoffM]

If Colston didn't get injured, he might very well have caught 100 passes. However his injury pretty much solidified him not getting it.

My vote goes to Reggie Bush. He's sixth in the league in receptions , and definately stretches defenses, allowing the Saints and Brees to pick apart defenses.

[kkirk1329]

I gotta vote for colston or young.

[Reel Deal]

The dude can run, but I just can't get past the fact that his passer rating is just horrid (ranked 31st out of the 32 starting QBs in the league).

[GeoffM]

A sign of things to come?

[Reel Deal]

Joke.

[omahilo]

aleast Bush finished 5th in the voting where he belongs... I thought for sure they would give him the award since he is Reggie Bush.

[Gordogg]

Hype at its finest.