You realize
I had the J5 and wasn't in the hand, right? The other guy mucked, so I'm not sure what he had, but based on how the hand played out, I put him on either 4

5

, 33, 22, maybe TT, or possibly K

Q

.
I don't know.... maybe he only had three Aces with a bad kicker. That doesn't really make much sense though, since he didn't raise preflop.