The TalkingPoker.com Forum

The TalkingPoker.com Forum (http://www.talkingpoker.com/forum/index.php)
-   General Poker Discussion (http://www.talkingpoker.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   30 day $5k from 5.50 and under SNG prop bet... (http://www.talkingpoker.com/forum/showthread.php?t=14023)

Talking Poker 06-03-08 03:07 AM

30 day $5k from 5.50 and under SNG prop bet...
 
Is it possible for one person to win $5000 in 30 days, playing $5.50 and less SNGs ONLY, and excluding 180 mans?

I'm thinking no.

So what kind of odds what you put on it? 3:2? 2:1? 5:1? What?

Windbreaker 06-03-08 10:20 AM

This would definately be extremely hard. I play 5 table SNGs, where my ROI is usually a lot greater than for a 1 table SNG. My best ever 500 SNG stretch gave me a return of slightly above 50% ROI....this was at $60 dollar buy ins. In one month I'm guessing I can get in about 1200 SNGs. At that rate, there's no way you would get it for $5.50s.

Even though the competition would be a lot easier, the only way you can possibly make that much is to run good for a long stretch and play high volume. Unless it's a SNG icons guy or one of the more respected SNG players, I don't see many guys can pull this off and even if they do....the prop bet must be huge in order for them to even want to follow through.

The odds I would give, depends on the player. Some guys can play 24 tables at once....those guys....I would give a lot less action, than a regular joe. For a normal player...3:1 ball park would be my guess.

Talking Poker 06-03-08 12:59 PM

Any other thoughts on this?

Dude is offering 2:1 that he can do it. In other words, bet $200 against him to win $100 if he fails. All money is being escrowed ahead of time and he's even got a webcam set up.

I'm in for AT LEAST $200, but I'm seriously considering making this a big bet.

I think even a SNG sicko could only pull this off one month in 4 (3:1), at the best.

is the thread, if anyone wants to read more about it or get in on the action. He's only going to run this if he stands to win at least $5k ($10k wagered), and it's not there yet.

2Tone 06-03-08 04:49 PM

Easy money?
 
Do you know/trust the guy? Winning that amount at those stakes in 30 days strikes as extremely unlikely. I'm shocked he'd be offering 2:1 -- 8:1 to 10:1 would seem more realistic to me.

My only caution would be the "too good to be true" factor and the amount he wants to bet -- $5k is decent amount, enough to go through a fair amount of trouble to set people up for. What is the risk this is an elaborate scam?

melioris 06-03-08 05:10 PM

I agree with 2tone, this has to be some kind of angle shoot.

Talking Poker 06-03-08 05:20 PM

0% chance it's a scam in the stealing people's money regard. He's having one of the mosty trusted people on the site hold all money (both sides) in escrow. That guy has like $44k staked out right now, so if he were to roll, the 5 or 10 or 15k from this would be fully recoverable from his investments.

So it's a 0% roll risk.

The only thinkg I'm worried about is if he has figured out some sort of loophole that is going to allow him to do that that no one has thought of. I just have to think SOMEONE would have figured it out by now. There was concern about the 180s, so he said he won't play any of them.

If anyone wants action on this and doesn't have an account there yet, I can do it for you (this will likely start before you get your account approved to post there). I'm in for $200 to win $100 right now, and amd still seriously considering increasing it. I keep thinking I must be missing something, but can't figure what it is.

Windbreaker 06-03-08 05:51 PM

Seems like you're getting way the best of it to me.

If you look at Spacegravy's sharkscope (he's a SNG Icon guy who is well ahead of pace for SNE this year), the most SNGs he played in a month is less than 3500.

Even if the guy can play that much, he needs an ROI of 26% in order for him to pull it off.

In addition, he stipulates that all tourneys are 5.50 or below. This eliminates the 6.50 buy in for 45 man SNGs...this is a huge disadvantage against him.

Too me...looking at his his OPR and Sharkscope, there is almost no way he can pull this off without some angleshoot.

I think if you use the sharkscope leaderboard....you can tell this task is nearly impossible without insane volume.

thrash1294 06-03-08 06:08 PM

DID he state that he would only play single table sngs?
Also what if he played in a$5.50 sng to satty to a mtt then cashed big in that?would that count?

Talking Poker 06-03-08 06:09 PM

I agree completely. I think I'm gonna bump up to $500 myself. Want some action?

It's not an angleshoot (that I can think of). The money is safe, it will be him playing (webcam), etc. I think he really thinks he can do it.

Talking Poker 06-03-08 06:11 PM

Go read the .

No sattys. No MTTs (well, MTT SNGs, like 45 mans, but not true large field MTTs). Not even 180s.

Talking Poker 06-03-08 06:19 PM

I PM'd a guy who was thinking about betting the max $2k and opted to not bet at all to ask him why. He replied with this:

I'm not sure about that math because I don't know how many SNGs one can play per hour, even if you are playing 25 at once, for example.

thrash1294 06-03-08 06:25 PM

It would take more than one single person playing under the screen name. A man has to sleep but a bot does not:twocents:
so running at an roi of 33% at single table sngs you would have to play aroun 2800 games. So thats aboout 95 a day plalying five at a time average time an hour per game 20hrs a day 4 hours of sleep a day.
Throw in some 45 man sngs.So the math says it can be done.But it would be hard to run that good for so long.

Talking Poker 06-03-08 07:02 PM

He will have a web cam set up - it's just him.

But why would he only play 5 at a time and not like 20 at a time, so he could play 1/4 as many hours per day?

Looking at the sharkscope leaderboard for "Any Game, $2.50-5.00, Avg. Profit for last 500 games," The top 20 list makes from $6.02 to $4.35 per game. Those are pretty sick numbers, but that's only a 500 game sample. #4 on the list is $5, btw. But let's just say this guy can somehow sustain $4 per game for 30 days (possible? I highly doubt it, but I don't know). To reach $5k, he'd need to get 1250 SNGs in. That's actually only 42 per day, which should be very doable.

I don't know. I don't think that's the best way to approach it though, because those numbers are unrealistic. I don't know what kind of ROI is sustainable playing so many tables for so many days. But if we go with a 30% ROI, that's only $1.65 per SNG, meaning he'd need to get in over 3000 of them.

Can you play 100 per day and maintain a 30% ROI?

I guess it's possible. Sure seem like it would be hell though. I'm pretty sure my money is safe. He'll crack at some point.

thrash1294 06-03-08 07:33 PM

ooooh the pressure :eek:
I would break roi to hard to maintain multi tabling:rolleyes:

sjay2k 06-03-08 08:59 PM

i think this is doable

Windbreaker 06-03-08 09:42 PM

I would have to look at it a bit more before making the bet.

The only angle shooting I can think of right now is that he states that he needs to profit $5000.00 or more by the 30 days. Well technically, he should win a few of the Battle of the Planets awards as a result of playing so much. It should be easy for him to post a high score on the High Orbit leader board for the two smaller buy in levels each week this runs. I'm not sure if in the rules this would count or not.

Aside from that, there's a few poor calculations. The 20% ROI over 6.5 hours a day is not realistic to achieve the $5000 goal over one month.

This assumes he's getting this ROI averaging 24 tables over that 6.5 hours. If any of you have actually tried playing 24 tables at once, (I have), your ROI will simply have to decrease as the table increase - unless you're use to it. Looking at his OPR and Sharkscope, I see no indication that he has ever been able to put in the volume like Spacegravy.

Also, the stipulation that all tourneys are held at $5.50 and under means that he can not play any $6.50 turbos for 45 player SNGs. He must play either $5 dollar regular SNGs and/or $3.25/45s.

Playing at regular SNGs slows down your hourly rate by quite a lot in a 45 man SNG - which hurts when volume - and that is the key for him to pull this off.

The only other thing I can think of right now, is that maybe he's really good at heads up SNGs? He would be able to play the 32 man heads up SNGs and profit a lot like that?

Other than that, I don't like his chances. Is this possible to do? For certain people I think they have a chance - like close to 1:1. From his past performance and all indications - it's highly unlikely.

2Tone 06-04-08 12:04 AM

Really?
 
Maybe. But reading the PTP thread, it strikes me as tremendously –EV for msusyr24.

Consider this very likely scenario. This guy, a very talented SNG player, grinds and grinds, eight, ten, 12 hours a days, playing 15 tables at a time. He makes upwards of 4k in the first 25 days, a remarkable achievement at these levels. But he hits a downswing, and ends up winning "only" about $3500 in 30 days.

He finishes the month completely burnt out on poker. And instead of having won enough for a nice vacation to recharge his batteries, he’s in the hole for $1500.

If he has the roll and talent to do something like this, why not play a reasonable amount of $100 SNGs? He could well make as much if not more, and much less risk of losing his mind.

I'm also reminded of this guy, who pulled it off ...

Gordogg 06-04-08 01:27 AM

I don't see how that's humanly possible. I'd definitely take that bet.

jhill3535 06-04-08 03:46 PM

I don't know if you saw it yet TP, but he changed the escrowing of the funds. Now if you have 10x the wager amount invested in the site you don't have to escrow, but he will still escrow 100% of his portion. This alleviates all the "money better used elsewhere" arguments.

That being said I just doubled down on my bet to $400.

I can see him hitting $2500 in the first 2 weeks, but I think the last week or 2 will kill him.

I am wondering though a bit about the BOP, as I don't think anyone has considered that. He does state in the official rules however that "Sharkscope will be used to verify everything." BOP winnings will not show up in SS, so I don't think he can use that to his advantage.

jhill3535 06-04-08 03:49 PM

Also, I think that pretty much everyone that has been winning the BOP has been playing 18 mans. I don't think anyone has won any at these lower levels playing 9 mans or 45 mans. He might be able to hit the high orbit with the 45s, but I don't know.

Talking Poker 06-04-08 03:59 PM

BOP shouldn't count (per his SS comment), but we should confirm that. He can't count that, FPPs, RB, Bonuses or anything like that. This is purely SNG profit.

And that's cool about not having to escrow. Good move on his part. I have more than 50x my bet amount invested, so I should be good to go. :thumbsup:

Wes 06-04-08 04:03 PM

Grinder today, legend forever

Talking Poker 06-04-08 04:13 PM

Confirmed:

I increased my bet to $300 and am tempted to go to 5.

None of you want in on this? Yes, I think it's POSSIBLE he can do this, but I think it's FAR more unlikely that 2:1.

Windbreaker 06-04-08 04:28 PM

jhill3535 - I don't think you understand how the BOP promo works. 45 man SNGs never counts in the promotion. However, it would pretty easy for any good player to make the top ten of the BOP high orbit with massive amounts of volume. Most people might be able to put in 100 SNGs for an orbit once in a week....for a high volume player, you probably could put in six or seven - makes it relatively easy to cash in the high orbit.

Looking at this now, I still don't like his chances at all. There are a few players out there that I have no questions that are better than even money on this wager. Eg. All the Supernova Elite SNG players, QuasiFiction and his brother DNA2RNA, and some of the SNG Icon players, etc.

Having said that, I'm probably going to pass on this bet. I would only want to make a large bet in order for this to be really worthwhile. I'm sure you guys are getting the best of this bet. Not many people can increase the volume of tables/hands so quickly and win at a significantly high rate. Also the 45-man SNGs won't be the deciding factor as to weather he wins this bet or not. The tables take quite some time to get started, the variance is high, and it takes a lot longer to finish than a single table tournament. To give you an example, over my hottest stretch over 500 games, I had a ROI slightly over 50%. At the 5 dollar level - that would only make him $1375. This would also take a lot longer to play out as the $5.50/45 players are regular speed SNGs. If he's winning this bet, it's definately not going to be a result of the 45s.

Wes 06-04-08 04:32 PM

Any idea how big of a grinder this guy is before this? If he's used to playing a ton, I wouldn't bet against him. If not, I will.

Talking Poker 06-04-08 04:36 PM

So why are you not going to take the bet? If you want to make a large bet to make it worthwhile, make a large bet. If you'd rather not escrow the money, I can work something out with you to get at least some of the action under me.

Windbreaker 06-04-08 04:47 PM

Not betting, because I think I'm missing something. If it sounds too good to be true....

I don't know...seems like he knows something I don't. Storm from what I can tell, the most he's ever played is 567 in a month (from Sharkscope). I'm guessing he's a student with time off now....but I don't see any signs that indicate he's ever multitable 16+ successivelly. (I could be totally wrong and he could be sitting this up???).

I don't know....something just doesn't feel right about it....not worth the potential 1k for a win.

Talking Poker 06-04-08 04:52 PM

4 Attachment(s)
SharkScope msusyr24 on Stars and Tilt.

Year 2008 data:
47 total games played on FT.
1574 total games played on Poker Stars.

If I do an advanced search by month for 2008, he's won over $2000 twice, but barely. His 2008 ROI on Stars is 43%.

But that's including everything. If I make this 2-45 players, no sattelites, but still all stakes, he's played 1405 tourneys in 2008 and has a 37% ROI.

Those are good numbers, but his total 2008 winnings using the above criteria (basically pulling out the 180s and sattys) is $4632.

So to win $5k in 30 days, he's going to have to significantly increase his volume. Maybe he thinks he can do this. But I personally think his ROI is going to drop when he plays crazy volume like that.

It should also be noted that if we filter out everything above $5, he omnly has 174 games played. So he's won most of that money at higher limits. He does have a 56% ROI for $5 and less (no sattys, 45 mans and lower) though.

The most games (filtered as above) he has played in a month so far was 537 in May.

Here are the graphs of his 2008 45 man and lower, no sattelies action...

Talking Poker 06-04-08 04:59 PM

FYI... there is about 7 hours left until he is either going to start this or pull it if he doesn't get enough action.

I suggested extending 48 hours, but unless he posts on 2p2 or something in addition, I'm not sure how much more action he's going to get.

msusyr24 06-04-08 05:09 PM

hey guys this is the guy running this challenge

give you some info on me

im a 20yr old student..just got out of school
i play basketball for the school and have 0 time to play during school

i've paid my way through college and been on my own since i was 15 100% through playing poker.

im a triple major and have turned my life around completely. i'd like to think i have a good head on my shoulders.

basically i think i can 15+ table successfully and imo think this is possible. the big thing will be volume, time, and if my roi will drop, and lastly if i will burn out.

this is why I put up the bet... I've always wanted to try this. I mean, the though of being able to make 5k in a month with like a $500 roll would provide me so much security in the back of my mind as far as if I ever need money in the future. I've simply never had the time/motivation to try. This will be a pain in the ass but an extra 5k+ in sidebets would make it worth the try.

AND here is my take on it. I'm guessing I will get ~10k in total action. that has my risk at 5k. i can guarantee you i will make at least 3k. therefore my MAX LOSS is 2k. I can handle that. Basically im risking 2k to win 12k+

If you have any other questions please let me know.

This is for no game higher than $5.50 and nothing with more than 45 players. No fpp tourneys, no satellites, etc etc

msusyr24 06-04-08 05:14 PM

also, i wouldn't put this up if I didn't think I could do this.

there really isn't anything "hidden" or any "loophole"

fwiw

jhill3535 06-04-08 05:14 PM

He made a statement of needing at least 10k in action (5k from him) in order for it not to hurt his hourly rate? I am not sure what to make from that because it doesn't appear that he has ever made $5k in a month from MTTs or SNGs.

msusyr24 06-04-08 05:20 PM

i dont think i ever mentioned hourly rate

what i meant was that i need some risk for this to be worth it.

if i only get 4k in action my risk is 2k. well i guarantee im going to make 3k in the 30 days so really my worst case scenario is a 1k profit.

lol if this starts off badly, knowing im still going to make money from this challenge really isn't anything that will push me to keep playing. losing several thousand or more would however.

msusyr24 06-04-08 05:22 PM

heading to class

Talking Poker 06-04-08 05:31 PM

msusyr just PM'd me about my idea of him posting this on 2p2. Like me, he has no cred there, so hasn't bothered. But if one of you guys who frequents 2p2 regularly and is trusted there is willing to cross post the info (I'm not sure how exactly you'd need to do it, if they allow linking to other sites, etc), he will give you 5% of the action you bring in IF HE WINS the bet.

So in other words, if you post on 2p2 and it brings in $5k in bets AND HE WINS, he'll pay you $250. And I get a cut too for coordinating this. :)

If no one does this, no big deal, but if one of you 2p2 regulars thinks this is something those guys would like to get in on, then by all means let them know about it. Please post here before doing so though, so we don't have like 3 people doing it.

Oh, and in case this is making you wonder, I get nothing for referring you guys or anything like that. He just PM'd me for the first time a few minutes ago. The reasons I started this thread were exactly what they appear to be - wondering if the SNG experts here though it was possible.

I'm still betting against him.

msusyr24 06-04-08 10:35 PM

taking bets for a couple more hours

may extend 24hrs but the challenge will have started by this point

WotaWaster 06-04-08 10:51 PM

I am the guy escrowing the money on PTP and have dealt with msusyr alot and there is 100% no angle planned.

He basically needs to play 3000 SNGs at 30% ROI or 4500 SNGS at 20% ROI.

He isn't going to use any bots/multiple players. he isnt hoping to include rakeback or anything. If he manages to play 4000 SNG's in a month playing his best game I expect him to win the bet. Doing that however is obviously the hard part. Its a pure volume/endurance test and whether he can maintain his best perfomance 10+ hrs a day for 30 days.

Talking Poker 06-05-08 12:15 AM

Welcome to the forum to you both.

GL with this msu... I'm betting against you, but I think this will be interesting, no matter how it ends, so I hope you decide to go for it.

msusyr24 06-05-08 01:32 PM

tyvm talking poker

and to everyone fwiw, i am accepting wagers for another 11hrs

starts at 12am est June 6th

msusyr24 06-05-08 01:45 PM

lol...didnt realize only 3 ppl have 5k+ profit THIS WHOLE YEAR in these games
 

MAYHEM45 06-05-08 01:52 PM

most sane people move up before then imo.

msusyr24 06-05-08 02:09 PM

i guess so

hackers238 06-05-08 03:44 PM

I would post at 2p2, but I frequent the micro Full Ring Cash forum, and I think the most you would get in action might be $300 :)

I also don't think those players know much about SNGs.

hackers238 06-05-08 03:50 PM

Hey, I'll post it anyway. Googled around and found a link to your PTP post.

Talking Poker 06-05-08 04:39 PM

You can find it in the first few posts in this thread too.

Make sure you tell them he's only accepting bets until midnight ET.

msusyr24 06-05-08 04:43 PM

tytytyty

Talking Poker 06-06-08 01:36 AM

He started at midnight (and already quit for the night).

Webcam is here:

jillaj 06-06-08 01:55 AM

damn shitty time not to check in for a few days. I would have gotten in on some of this.

Talking Poker 06-06-08 02:17 AM

You're only 2 hours past the deadline and he is asleep. If you ship the money to Wota now (see above, or actually PTP link, I guess), I'm sure he'll take your action. If not, Wota will ship it back.

Can't hurt to try if you want in.

Wes 06-07-08 02:35 AM

I got 1600 posts on 2+2 and am somewhat respected I think. Still need someone to post this on 2+2?


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:52 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©2004-2008 TalkingPoker.com